I have seen it where server 1 can't create databases on server2. You might want to check they are both in localdomainservers.
If that is not the issues then have a look at this link.
http://www.seanbutler.co.uk/QuickplaceAdmin.htm
It shows you how to set QuickplaceStubMakerLogging. This should show you what is going wrong.
Good luck.